New Supreme Court resolution – are we facing a slowdown in the operation of the Public Procurement Court

10 May 2023 | Knowledge, News, The Right Focus

On 26 April 2023, the Labour Chamber of the Supreme Court issued a resolution stating that the hearing of a civil case by a single judge in a court of second instance as allowed under the so-called Anti-Covid Act, restricts the right to a fair trial, as it is not necessary for the protection of public health, and will render the proceedings invalid. The resolution has the force of a legal rule and is effective from the date of its adoption.

What should be the composition of the court of second instance

In accordance with the Code of Civil Procedure, in appeal proceedings, cases are heard by a panel of three judges. An exception to this rule was only established by the Anti-Covid Act, which – due to the threats posed by the pandemic – allowed for single judges to hear cases.

Supreme Court resolution and the public procurement market

Apparently, the Supreme Court’s resolution might seem to have no particular relevance to the public procurement market.

This is because the Public Procurement Law has established a separate institution which examines disputes arising in the context of public procurement procedures, namely the National Appeal Chamber (Krajowa Izba Odwoławcza, KIO).

However, judgments rendered by the National Appeal Chamber may be appealed to the Public Procurement Court, i.e. the Regional Court in Warsaw, which applies the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure on appeals and thus, also those concerning the composition of the court. In other words, the rule here is a panel of three judges.

Consequences of the new Supreme Court resolution

At present, it is difficult to clearly foresee the effects of the new resolution of the Supreme Court.

According to publicly available information, the Regional Court in Warsaw (and therefore also the 23rd Commercial Appeals and Public Procurement Division, which handles appeals) intends to comply with the resolution.

The immediate consequence of this decision has been the cancellation of some scheduled hearings and the addition of judges to adjudicating panels. In the future, this may also mean that appeal proceedings will be lengthened.

How do we assist in proceedings before the Public Procurement Court?

  • Review documents relating to public contract procedures and appeal proceedings before the National Appeal Chamber
  • Analyse the grounds of lodging an appeal against decisions of the National Appeal Chamber
  • Draft appeals against decisions of the National Appeal Chamber or replies to appeals, and represent parties before the Public Procurement Court

Questions? Contact the authors

Jakub Krysa, Ph.D.

Michał Waraksa

Latest Knowledge

The Polish Deposit and Return System: a guide to the legal and tax rules

The Polish Deposit and Return System launches on 1 October. This is a real revolution for businesses, whether they are producers, importers, distributors or traders. Indeed, its implementation brings with it a number of challenges, including, perhaps less obviously, concerning VAT. Here is a brief guide to the most important issues relating to the Polish Deposit and Return System.

Act Amending the Labour Code or Poland’s response to the Equal Pay Directive

On 3 April 2025, a new draft Act Amending the Labour Code appeared on the website of the Sejm. Prepared by the Extraordinary Committee for Codification Amendments, it differs significantly from the original parliamentary draft implementing the Directive (print no. 934), the first reading of which took place on 6 February 2025. On 9 May 2025, the Sejm adopted the bill without amendments.

How a family foundation can protect itself from ‘black sheep’

Every family may unfortunately have members who can be confrontational, aggressive and uncooperative, who are in addition convinced that they are always right and that the world is always against them. They can create chaos and confusion, are a source of constant conflict or simply do not fit into the overall harmony. Sometimes we call them ‘black sheep’ because they cause difficult situations, place stress on relations or fail to meet expectations.

Key changes in tax scheme reporting (MDR)

The significant changes in the tax environment and the growing expectations for fiscal transparency have prompted the legislature to streamline the existing provisions on the system for reporting tax schemes (MDR), thereby eliminating some procedural ambiguities. According to ministerial announcements, the main aim of the amendments is to improve the readability, clarity and consistency of the reporting system and more closely align it with that in force in the wider EU.

Amendments to the General Tax Code

The Polish tax system could be in for a revolution. The Ministry of Finance has announced draft changes aimed at simplifying, streamlining and, in some areas, tightening the rules for dealing with the tax authorities.

Contact us:

Jakub Krysa, PhD

Jakub Krysa, PhD

Attorney at Law, Of Counsel, Public Procurement

+48 784 084 522

j.krysa@kochanski.pl