Public IT contracts may involve unusual forms of remuneration 

23 August 2023 | Knowledge, News

A characteristic of every public contract is remuneration. Contracts that do not involve remuneration (e.g. donation or lending contracts) are not public contracts within the meaning of the Public Procurement Law Act and therefore do not fall under the Act. As a result, contracting authorities are free to enter into contracts without remuneration, in particular without having to publish relevant announcements or carry out formalised tender procedures. However, it is important to note that the concept of remuneration has its own autonomous definition under both the EU procurement directives and the national PPL Act, which in many cases differs from the common understanding of payment. As a result, determining whether a particular contract involves remuneration and is therefore subject to the PPL Act can often be a significant challenge for contracting authorities.

Examples of IT contracts

This can be seen through the lens of public IT contracts, which by their very nature can involve unusual forms of remuneration and may appear at first glance to be performed free of charge.

Such contracts may concern, for example, the implementation of innovative software or applications, the development of an IT system owned and used by a contracting authority, or the replacement of one particular IT solution with another.

In many cases, contracting authorities conclude these contracts without a tendering procedure, believing that they are free of charge.

Unusual forms of payment by contracting authorities

For example, economic operators may provide apparently free software to contracting authorities in return for the obligation to use or develop the software and to provide economic operators with reports and updates or modifications developed. It may also be the case that economic operators expect contracting authorities to allow access to their database in return for the software provided.

In such a scenario, economic operators do not receive any monetary remuneration from contracting authorities in return for the software.

However, this does not automatically mean that such contracts are free of charge within the meaning of the PPL Act and may therefore be concluded without applying its provisions. This is because each such contract should be subject to an individual analysis, primarily taking into account the following issues:

  • Does an economic operator gain an economic advantage via such a contract?
  • Is a contracting authority obliged to render a reciprocal performance in return for an economic operator’s performance?
  • Does the contracting authority obligation arise from the contract in such a way that it can be enforced in court?

A positive answer to all of the above questions may lead to the conclusion that a contract involves remuneration and should therefore be concluded under one of the procedures provided for in the PPL Act.

Source: Rzeczpospolita

Date: 23.08.2023

Any questions? Contact us

Jakub Krysa

Michał Waraksa

Latest Knowledge

How to structure a family foundation wisely

One of the key advantages of a family foundation is the flexibility to shape its internal structure as required. The legislature has granted the founders considerable freedom in this respect, enabling the foundation to be adapted to specific financial, family and business needs.

New rules for employing foreigners

The long-awaited Act on the Conditions for the Admissibility of Entrusting Work to Foreigners in the Republic of Poland came into force on 1 June 2025, replacing the previous legislation on employment promotion and labour market institutions.

The UDER2 draft: (theoretically) strengthened principle in dubio pro tributario

This principle, which states that doubts should be resolved in favour of the taxpayer, is set out in Article 2a of the General Tax Code and applies only in cases involving vague regulations. In practice, this leaves the tax authorities with considerable leeway for arbitrary application in proceedings where factual findings are crucial.

The Polish Deposit and Return System: a guide to the legal and tax rules

The Polish Deposit and Return System launches on 1 October. This is a real revolution for businesses, whether they are producers, importers, distributors or traders. Indeed, its implementation brings with it a number of challenges, including, perhaps less obviously, concerning VAT. Here is a brief guide to the most important issues relating to the Polish Deposit and Return System.

Act Amending the Labour Code or Poland’s response to the Equal Pay Directive

On 3 April 2025, a new draft Act Amending the Labour Code appeared on the website of the Sejm. Prepared by the Extraordinary Committee for Codification Amendments, it differs significantly from the original parliamentary draft implementing the Directive (print no. 934), the first reading of which took place on 6 February 2025. On 9 May 2025, the Sejm adopted the bill without amendments.

How a family foundation can protect itself from ‘black sheep’

Every family may unfortunately have members who can be confrontational, aggressive and uncooperative, who are in addition convinced that they are always right and that the world is always against them. They can create chaos and confusion, are a source of constant conflict or simply do not fit into the overall harmony. Sometimes we call them ‘black sheep’ because they cause difficult situations, place stress on relations or fail to meet expectations.

Key changes in tax scheme reporting (MDR)

The significant changes in the tax environment and the growing expectations for fiscal transparency have prompted the legislature to streamline the existing provisions on the system for reporting tax schemes (MDR), thereby eliminating some procedural ambiguities. According to ministerial announcements, the main aim of the amendments is to improve the readability, clarity and consistency of the reporting system and more closely align it with that in force in the wider EU.

Contact us:

Jakub Krysa, PhD

Jakub Krysa, PhD

Attorney at Law, Of Counsel, Public Procurement

+48 784 084 522

j.krysa@kochanski.pl