Can WIBOR be replaced by another benchmark in home mortgage agreements only?

11 May 2022 | Knowledge, News

Due to rising interest rates and a significant increase in mortgage repayments, several ideas have recently emerged to support borrowers. In particular, according to a preliminary government proposal, in home mortgage loans (including existing ones) the WIBOR benchmark would be replaced with another benchmark, while WIBOR would continue to apply to other types of loan agreements. However, the legal feasibility of such a solution is worth exploring.

To assess whether WIBOR may be replaced by another index in existing loan agreements with the interest rate based on WIBOR, one must first consider that WIBOR is functioning under the legal regime of Regulation (EU) 2016/1011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 8 June 2016 on indices used as benchmarks in financial instruments (…), i.e. the so-called Benchmark Regulation (BMR).

WIBOR was selected by the Polish Financial Supervision Authority (KNF) and accepted by the European Commission as the so-called “critical benchmark” within the meaning of the BMR.  Consequently, in principle, this benchmark may only be set aside and replaced by another benchmark in loan agreements in compliance with the detailed procedure set out in the BMR.

In accordance with the BMR, the new benchmark should replace, by operation of law, any reference to the former benchmark in all types of agreements and instruments mentioned in the BMR.

However, according to representatives of the ruling camp, the plan to replace WIBOR with another benchmark would apply only to home mortgage loans, while WIBOR would remain the benchmark applicable to other types of loan agreements, in particular concerning loans for business entities and consumer loans.

Such solution seems difficult to reconcile with the BMR, since according to this Regulation the replacement of one critical benchmark with another should lead to the complete cessation of the use of the benchmark being replaced – in this case WIBOR.

Moreover, in accordance with the BMR the new benchmark should replace, by operation of law, any reference to the former benchmark in all types of agreements and instruments referred to in the BMR, and it is thus impossible to implement replacement in only certain types of agreements.

Source: aleBank.pl

Date: 28 April 2022

Latest Knowledge

Unitary Patent & Unified Patent Court – a revolution in patent protection

After years of discussion and preparation, the EU’s unitary patent system is becoming a reality and is expected to start on 1 June 2023. This is a real revolution in patent protection in the European Union, as with the entry into force of the unitary system, the Unified Patent Court will also commence its activities.

National e-Invoicing System | Tax Focus

On 15 March this year, the Standing Committee of the Council of Ministers gave its favourable opinion on a bill concerning amendments to the VAT Act and certain other acts in connection with the introduction of a mandatory National e-Invoicing System (KSeF).

Pledge as security for financing

In the current economic situation and with inflation constantly on the rise, companies are increasingly looking for external financing to maintain their business at its current level or to ensure continued growth.

Latest amendments to the Labour Code

On 4 April 2023, the Act of 9 March 2023 amending the Labour Code was published. The changes will come into force after 21 days, i.e. on 26 April 2023.